| Links User Guide Reference Apache Tomcat Development | Apache Tomcat 6.0JNDI Resources HOW-TO| Introduction |  | 
Tomcat 6 provides a JNDI InitialContext implementation
instance for each web application running under it, in a manner that is 
compatible with those provided by a 
Java2 Enterprise Edition application 
server. The J2EE standard provides a standard set of elements in the
/WEB-INF/web.xmlfile to reference/define resources. See the following Specifications for more information about programming APIs
for JNDI, and for the features supported by Java2 Enterprise Edition (J2EE)
servers, which Tomcat emulates for the services that it provides: | 
 | web.xml configuration |  | 
The following elements may be used in the web application deployment
descriptor (/WEB-INF/web.xml) of your web application to define
resources: 
<env-entry>- Environment entry, a
    single-value parameter that can be used to configure how the application
    will operate.<resource-ref>- Resource reference,
    which is typically to an object factory for resources such as a JDBCDataSource, a JavaMailSession, or custom
    object factories configured into Tomcat 6.<resource-env-ref>- Resource
    environment reference, a new variation ofresource-refadded in Servlet 2.4 that is simpler to configure for resources
    that do not require authentication information. Providing that Tomcat is able to identify an appropriate resource factory to
use to create the resource and that no further configuration information is
required, Tomcat will use the information in /WEB-INF/web.xmlto
create the resource. | 
 | context.xml configuration |  | 
If Tomcat is unable to identify the appropriate resource factory and/or
additional configuration information is required, additional Tomcat specific
configuration must be specified before Tomcat can create the resource.
Tomcat specific resource configuration is entered in
the <Context>elements that
can be specified in either$CATALINA_BASE/conf/server.xmlor,
preferably, the per-web-application context XML file
(META-INF/context.xml). Tomcat specific resource configuration is performed using the following
elements in the <Context>element: 
<Environment> -
    Configure names and values for scalar environment entries that will be
    exposed to the web application through the JNDI
    InitialContext(equivalent to the inclusion of an<env-entry>element in the web application
    deployment descriptor).<Resource> -
    Configure the name and data type of a resource made available to the
    application (equivalent to the inclusion of a
    <resource-ref>element in the web application
    deployment descriptor).<ResourceLink> -
    Add a link to a resource defined in the global JNDI context. Use resource 
    links to give a web application access to a resource defined in 
    the <GlobalNamingResources>
    child element of the <Server>
    element.<Transaction> -
    Add a resource factory for instantiating the UserTransaction object 
    instance that is available at java:comp/UserTransaction. Any number of these elements may be nested inside a
<Context>element and will
be associated only with that particular web application. If a resource has been defined in a
<Context>element it is not
necessary for that resource to be defined in/WEB-INF/web.xml.
However, it is recommended to keep the entry in/WEB-INF/web.xmlto document the resource requirements for the web application. Where the same resource name has been defined for a
<env-entry>element included in the web application
deployment descriptor (/WEB-INF/web.xml) and in an<Environment>element as part of the<Context>element for the
web application, the values in the deployment descriptor will take precedence
only if allowed by the corresponding<Environment>element (by setting theoverrideattribute to "true"). | 
 | Global configuration |  | 
Tomcat 6 maintains a separate namespace of global resources for the 
entire server.  These are configured in the 
<GlobalNamingResources>element of$CATALINA_BASE/conf/server.xml. You may expose these resources to 
web applications by using a 
<ResourceLink> to
include it in the per-web-application context. If a resource has been defined using a 
<ResourceLink>, it is not
necessary for that resource to be defined in /WEB-INF/web.xml.
However, it is recommended to keep the entry in/WEB-INF/web.xmlto document the resource requirements for the web application. | 
 | Tomcat Standard Resource Factories |  | 
  Tomcat 6 includes a series of standard resource factories that can
  provide services to your web applications, but give you configuration
  flexibility (via the
  <Context>element)
  without modifying the web application or the deployment descriptor. Each
  subsection below details the configuration and usage of the standard resource
  factories. See Adding Custom
  Resource Factories for information about how to create, install,
  configure, and use your own custom resource factory classes with
  Tomcat 6. NOTE - Of the standard resource factories, only the
  "JDBC Data Source" and "User Transaction" factories are mandated to
  be available on other platforms, and then they are required only if
  the platform implements the Java2 Enterprise Edition (J2EE) specs.
  All other standard resource factories, plus custom resource factories
  that you write yourself, are specific to Tomcat and cannot be assumed
  to be available on other containers. | Generic JavaBean Resources |  | 
    0.  IntroductionThis resource factory can be used to create objects of any
    Java class that conforms to standard JavaBeans naming conventions (i.e.
    it has a zero-arguments constructor, and has property setters that
    conform to the setFoo() naming pattern.  The resource factory will
    create a new instance of the appropriate bean class every time a
    lookup()for this entry is made. The steps required to use this facility are described below. 1.  Create Your JavaBean ClassCreate the JavaBean class which will be instantiated each time
    that the resource factory is looked up.  For this example, assume
    you create a class com.mycompany.MyBean, which looks
    like this: |  |  |  |  |  | 
package com.mycompany;
public class MyBean {
  private String foo = "Default Foo";
  public String getFoo() {
    return (this.foo);
  }
  public void setFoo(String foo) {
    this.foo = foo;
  }
  private int bar = 0;
  public int getBar() {
    return (this.bar);
  }
  public void setBar(int bar) {
    this.bar = bar;
  }
}
 |  |  |  |  |  | 
2.  Declare Your Resource RequirementsNext, modify your web application deployment descriptor
  (/WEB-INF/web.xml) to declare the JNDI name under which
  you will request new instances of this bean.  The simplest approach is
  to use a<resource-env-ref>element, like this: |  |  |  |  |  | 
<resource-env-ref>
  <description>
    Object factory for MyBean instances.
  </description>
  <resource-env-ref-name>
    bean/MyBeanFactory
  </resource-env-ref-name>
  <resource-env-ref-type>
    com.mycompany.MyBean
  </resource-env-ref-type>
</resource-env-ref>
 |  |  |  |  |  | 
WARNING - Be sure you respect the element ordering
    that is required by the DTD for web application deployment descriptors!
    See the
    Servlet
    Specification for details. 3.  Code Your Application's Use Of This ResourceA typical use of this resource environment reference might look
  like this: |  |  |  |  |  | 
Context initCtx = new InitialContext();
Context envCtx = (Context) initCtx.lookup("java:comp/env");
MyBean bean = (MyBean) envCtx.lookup("bean/MyBeanFactory");
writer.println("foo = " + bean.getFoo() + ", bar = " +
               bean.getBar());
 |  |  |  |  |  | 
4.  Configure Tomcat's Resource FactoryTo configure Tomcat's resource factory, add an element like this to the
    <Context>element for
    this web application. |  |  |  |  |  | 
<Context ...>
  ...
  <Resource name="bean/MyBeanFactory" auth="Container"
            type="com.mycompany.MyBean"
            factory="org.apache.naming.factory.BeanFactory"
            bar="23"/>
  ...
</Context>
 |  |  |  |  |  | 
Note that the resource name (here, bean/MyBeanFactorymust match the value specified in the web application deployment
    descriptor.  We are also initializing the value of thebarproperty, which will causesetBar(23)to be called before
    the new bean is returned.  Because we are not initializing thefooproperty (although we could have), the bean will
    contain whatever default value is set up by its constructor. | 
 | JavaMail Sessions |  | 
    0.  IntroductionIn many web applications, sending electronic mail messages is a
    required part of the system's functionality.  The
    Java Mail API
    makes this process relatively straightforward, but requires many
    configuration details that the client application must be aware of
    (including the name of the SMTP host to be used for message sending). Tomcat 6 includes a standard resource factory that will create
    javax.mail.Sessionsession instances for you, already
    configured to connect to an SMTP server.
    In this way, the application is totally insulated from changes in the
    email server configuration environment - it simply asks for, and receives,
    a preconfigured session whenever needed. The steps required for this are outlined below. 1.  Declare Your Resource RequirementsThe first thing you should do is modify the web application deployment
    descriptor (/WEB-INF/web.xml) to declare the JNDI name under
    which you will look up preconfigured sessions.  By convention, all such
    names should resolve to themailsubcontext (relative to the
    standardjava:comp/envnaming context that is the root of
    all provided resource factories.  A typicalweb.xmlentry
    might look like this: |  |  |  |  |  | 
<resource-ref>
  <description>
    Resource reference to a factory for javax.mail.Session
    instances that may be used for sending electronic mail
    messages, preconfigured to connect to the appropriate
    SMTP server.
  </description>
  <res-ref-name>
    mail/Session
  </res-ref-name>
  <res-type>
    javax.mail.Session
  </res-type>
  <res-auth>
    Container
  </res-auth>
</resource-ref>
 |  |  |  |  |  | 
WARNING - Be sure you respect the element ordering
    that is required by the DTD for web application deployment descriptors!
    See the
    Servlet
    Specification for details. 2.  Code Your Application's Use Of This ResourceA typical use of this resource reference might look like this: |  |  |  |  |  | 
Context initCtx = new InitialContext();
Context envCtx = (Context) initCtx.lookup("java:comp/env");
Session session = (Session) envCtx.lookup("mail/Session");
Message message = new MimeMessage(session);
message.setFrom(new InternetAddress(request.getParameter("from")));
InternetAddress to[] = new InternetAddress[1];
to[0] = new InternetAddress(request.getParameter("to"));
message.setRecipients(Message.RecipientType.TO, to);
message.setSubject(request.getParameter("subject"));
message.setContent(request.getParameter("content"), "text/plain");
Transport.send(message);
 |  |  |  |  |  | 
Note that the application uses the same resource reference name
    that was declared in the web application deployment descriptor.  This
    is matched up against the resource factory that is configured in the
    <Context>element
    for the web application as described below. 3.  Configure Tomcat's Resource FactoryTo configure Tomcat's resource factory, add an elements like this to the
    <Context>element for
    this web application. |  |  |  |  |  | 
<Context ...>
  ...
  <Resource name="mail/Session" auth="Container"
            type="javax.mail.Session"
            mail.smtp.host="localhost"/>
  ...
</Context>
 |  |  |  |  |  | 
Note that the resource name (here, mail/Session) must
    match the value specified in the web application deployment descriptor.
    Customize the value of themail.smtp.hostparameter to
    point at the server that provides SMTP service for your network. Additional resource attributes and values will be converted to properties
    and values and passed to
    javax.mail.Session.getInstance(java.util.Properties)as part of
    thejava.util.Propertiescollection. In addition to the
    properties defined in Annex A of the JavaMail specification, individual
    providers may also support additional properties. Tomcat's resource factory provides a passwordproperty
    which can be configured by addingpassword="yourpassword"to the Resource definition. 4.  Install the JavaMail libraries
    Download the JavaMail API.  The JavaMail API requires the Java Activation
    Framework (JAF) API as well.  The Java Activation Framework is included in
    Java SE 6 onwards. Java SE 5 users can download the latest version, 
    
    JAF 1.1.1.
     Unpackage the distribution(s) and place mail.jar (and activation.jar if
    required) into $CATALINA_HOME/lib so the JAR(s) is(are) available to Tomcat
    during the initialization of the mail Session Resource.
    Note: placing jars in both $CATALINA_HOME/lib and a web
    application's lib folder will cause an error, so ensure mail.jar (and
    activation.jar) is(are) placed only the $CATALINA_HOME/lib location.
     Example ApplicationThe /examplesapplication included with Tomcat contains
    an example of utilizing this resource factory.  It is accessed via the
    "JSP Examples" link.  The source code for the servlet that actually
    sends the mail message is in/WEB-INF/classes/SendMailServlet.java. WARNING - The default configuration assumes that there
    is an SMTP server listing on port 25 on localhost. If this is
    not the case, edit the<Context>element for
    this web application and modify the parameter value for themail.smtp.hostparameter to be the host name of an SMTP server
    on your network. | 
 | JDBC Data Sources |  | 
    0.  IntroductionMany web applications need to access a database via a JDBC driver,
    to support the functionality required by that application.  The J2EE
    Platform Specification requires J2EE Application Servers to make
    available a DataSource implementation (that is, a connection
    pool for JDBC connections) for this purpose.  Tomcat 6 offers exactly
    the same support, so that database-based applications you develop on
    Tomcat using this service will run unchanged on any J2EE server. For information about JDBC, you should consult the following: NOTE - The default data source support in Tomcat
    is based on the DBCP connection pool from the
    Commons
    project.  However, it is possible to use any other connection pool
    that implements javax.sql.DataSource, by writing your
    own custom resource factory, as described
    below. 1.  Install Your JDBC DriverUse of the JDBC Data Sources JNDI Resource Factory requires
    that you make an appropriate JDBC driver available to both Tomcat internal
    classes and to your web application.  This is most easily accomplished by
    installing the driver's JAR file(s) into the
    $CATALINA_HOME/libdirectory, which makes the driver
    available both to the resource factory and to your application. 2.  Declare Your Resource RequirementsNext, modify the web application deployment descriptor
    (/WEB-INF/web.xml) to declare the JNDI name under
    which you will look up preconfigured data source.  By convention, all such
    names should resolve to thejdbcsubcontext (relative to the
    standardjava:comp/envnaming context that is the root of
    all provided resource factories.  A typicalweb.xmlentry
    might look like this: |  |  |  |  |  | 
<resource-ref>
  <description>
    Resource reference to a factory for java.sql.Connection
    instances that may be used for talking to a particular
    database that is configured in the <Context>
    configurartion for the web application.
  </description>
  <res-ref-name>
    jdbc/EmployeeDB
  </res-ref-name>
  <res-type>
    javax.sql.DataSource
  </res-type>
  <res-auth>
    Container
  </res-auth>
</resource-ref>
 |  |  |  |  |  | 
WARNING - Be sure you respect the element ordering
    that is required by the DTD for web application deployment descriptors!
    See the
    Servlet
    Specification for details. 3.  Code Your Application's Use Of This ResourceA typical use of this resource reference might look like this: |  |  |  |  |  | 
Context initCtx = new InitialContext();
Context envCtx = (Context) initCtx.lookup("java:comp/env");
DataSource ds = (DataSource)
  envCtx.lookup("jdbc/EmployeeDB");
Connection conn = ds.getConnection();
... use this connection to access the database ...
conn.close();
 |  |  |  |  |  | 
Note that the application uses the same resource reference name that was
    declared in the web application deployment descriptor. This is matched up
    against the resource factory that is configured in the
    <Context>element for
    the web application as described below. 4.  Configure Tomcat's Resource FactoryTo configure Tomcat's resource factory, add an element like this to the
    <Context>element for
    the web application. |  |  |  |  |  | 
<Context ...>
  ...
  <Resource name="jdbc/EmployeeDB"
            auth="Container"
            type="javax.sql.DataSource"
            username="dbusername"
            password="dbpassword"
            driverClassName="org.hsql.jdbcDriver"
            url="jdbc:HypersonicSQL:database"
            maxActive="8"
            maxIdle="4"/>
  ...
</Context>
 |  |  |  |  |  | 
Note that the resource name (here, jdbc/EmployeeDB) must
    match the value specified in the web application deployment descriptor. This example assumes that you are using the HypersonicSQL database
    JDBC driver.  Customize the driverClassNameanddriverNameparameters to match your actual database's
    JDBC driver and connection URL. The configuration properties for Tomcat's standard data source
    resource factory
    (org.apache.tomcat.dbcp.dbcp.BasicDataSourceFactory) are
    as follows: 
    driverClassName - Fully qualified Java class name
        of the JDBC driver to be used.username - Database username to be passed to our
        JDBC driver.password - Database password to be passed to our
        JDBC driver.url - Connection URL to be passed to our JDBC driver.
        (For backwards compatibility, the property driverNameis also recognized.)initialSize - The initial number of connections
        that will be created in the pool during pool initialization. Default: 0maxActive - The maximum number of connections
        that can be allocated from this pool at the same time. Default: 8minIdle - The minimum number of connections that
        will sit idle in this pool at the same time. Default: 0maxIdle - The maximum number of connections that
        can sit idle in this pool at the same time. Default: 8maxWait - The maximum number of milliseconds that the
        pool will wait (when there are no available connections) for a
        connection to be returned before throwing an exception. Default: -1 (infinite) Some additional properties handle connection validation: 
    validationQuery - SQL query that can be used by the
        pool to validate connections before they are returned to the
        application.  If specified, this query MUST be an SQL SELECT
        statement that returns at least one row.validationQueryTimeout - Timeout in seconds
        for the validation query to return. Default: -1 (infinite)testOnBorrow - true or false: whether a connection
        should be validated using the validation query each time it is
        borrowed from the pool. Default: truetestOnReturn - true or false: whether a connection
        should be validated using the validation query each time it is
        returned to the pool. Default: false The optional evictor thread is responsible for shrinking the pool
    by removing any conections which are idle for a long time. The evictor
    does not respect minIdle. Note that you do not need to
    activate the evictor thread if you only want the pool to shrink according
    to the configuredmaxIdleproperty. The evictor is disabled by default and can be configured using
    the following properties: 
    timeBetweenEvictionRunsMillis - The number of
        milliseconds between consecutive runs of the evictor.
        Default: -1 (disabled)numTestsPerEvictionRun - The number of connections
        that will be checked for idleness by the evitor during each
        run of the evictor. Default: 3minEvictableIdleTimeMillis - The idle time in
        milliseconds after which a connection can be removed from the pool
        by the evictor. Default: 30*60*1000 (30 minutes)testWhileIdle - true or false: whether a connection
        should be validated by the evictor thread using the validation query
        while sitting idle in the pool. Default: false Another optional feature is the removal of abandoned connections.
    A connection is called abandoned if the application does not return it
    to the pool for a long time. The pool can close such connections
    automatically and remove them from the pool. This is a workaround
    for applications leaking connections. The abandoning feature is disabled by default and can be configured
    using the following properties: 
    removeAbandoned - true or false: whether to
        remove abandoned connections from the pool. Default: falseremoveAbandonedTimeout - The number of
        seconds after which a borrowed connection is assumed to be abandoned.
        Default: 300logAbandoned - true or false: whether to log
        stack traces for application code which abandoned a statement
        or connection. This adds serious overhead. Default: false Finally there are various properties that allow further fine tuning
    of the pool behaviour: 
    defaultAutoCommit - true or false: default
        auto-commit state of the connections created by this pool.
        Default: truedefaultReadOnly - true or false: default
        read-only state of the connections created by this pool.
        Default: falsedefaultTransactionIsolation - This sets the
        default transaction isolation level. Can be one of
        NONE,READ_COMMITTED,READ_UNCOMMITTED,REPEATABLE_READ,SERIALIZABLE. Default: no default setpoolPreparedStatements - true or false: whether to
        pool PreparedStatements and CallableStatements. Default: falsemaxOpenPreparedStatements - The maximum number of open
        statements that can be allocated from the statement pool at the same time.
        Default: -1 (unlimited)defaultCatalog - The name of the default catalog.
        Default: not setconnectionInitSqls - A list of SQL statements
        run once after a Connection is created. Separate multiple statements
        by semicolons (;). Default: no statementconnectionProperties - A list of driver specific
        properties passed to the driver for creating connections. Each
        property is given as name=value, multiple properties
        are separated by semicolons (;). Default: no propertiesaccessToUnderlyingConnectionAllowed - true or false: whether
        accessing the underlying connections is allowed. Default: false For more details, please refer to the commons-dbcp documentation. | 
 | 
 | Adding Custom Resource Factories |  | 
  If none of the standard resource factories meet your needs, you can write
  your own factory and integrate it into Tomcat 6, and then configure the use
  of this factory in the
  <Context>element for
  the web application. In the example below, we will create a factory that only
  knows how to createcom.mycompany.MyBeanbeans from the
  Generic JavaBean Resources example
  above. 1.  Write A Resource Factory ClassYou must write a class that implements the JNDI service provider
  javax.naming.spi.ObjectFactoryinteface.  Every time your
  web application callslookup()on a context entry that is
  bound to this factory, thegetObjectInstance()method is
  called, with the following arguments: 
  Object obj - The (possibly null) object containing
      location or reference information that can be used in creating an object.
      For Tomcat, this will always be an object of type
      javax.naming.Reference, which contains the class name of
      this factory class, as well as the configuration properties (from the<Context>for the
      web application) to use in creating objects to be returned.Name name - The name to which this factory is bound
      relative to nameCtx, ornullif no name
      is specified.Context nameCtx - The context relative to which the
      nameparameter is specified, ornullifnameis relative to the default initial context.Hashtable environment - The (possibly null)
      environment that is used in creating this object.  This is generally
      ignored in Tomcat object factories. To create a resource factory that knows how to produce MyBeaninstances, you might create a class like this: |  |  |  |  |  | 
package com.mycompany;
import java.util.Enumeration;
import java.util.Hashtable;
import javax.naming.Context;
import javax.naming.Name;
import javax.naming.NamingException;
import javax.naming.RefAddr;
import javax.naming.Reference;
import javax.naming.spi.ObjectFactory;
public class MyBeanFactory implements ObjectFactory {
  public Object getObjectInstance(Object obj,
      Name name2, Context nameCtx, Hashtable environment)
      throws NamingException {
      // Acquire an instance of our specified bean class
      MyBean bean = new MyBean();
      // Customize the bean properties from our attributes
      Reference ref = (Reference) obj;
      Enumeration addrs = ref.getAll();
      while (addrs.hasMoreElements()) {
          RefAddr addr = (RefAddr) addrs.nextElement();
          String name = addr.getType();
          String value = (String) addr.getContent();
          if (name.equals("foo")) {
              bean.setFoo(value);
          } else if (name.equals("bar")) {
              try {
                  bean.setBar(Integer.parseInt(value));
              } catch (NumberFormatException e) {
                  throw new NamingException("Invalid 'bar' value " + value);
              }
          }
      }
      // Return the customized instance
      return (bean);
  }
}
 |  |  |  |  |  | 
In this example, we are unconditionally creating a new instance of
  the com.mycompany.MyBeanclass, and populating its properties
  based on the parameters included in the<ResourceParams>element that configures this factory (see below).  You should note that any
  parameter namedfactoryshould be skipped - that parameter is
  used to specify the name of the factory class itself (in this case,com.mycompany.MyBeanFactory) rather than a property of the
  bean being configured. For more information about ObjectFactory, see the
  JNDI 1.2 Service
  Provider Interface (SPI) Specification. You will need to compile this class against a class path that includes
  all of the JAR files in the $CATALINA_HOME/libdirectory.  When you are through,
  place the factory class (and the corresponding bean class) unpacked under$CATALINA_HOME/lib, or in a JAR file inside$CATALINA_HOME/lib.  In this way, the required class
  files are visible to both Catalina internal resources and your web
  application. 2.  Declare Your Resource RequirementsNext, modify your web application deployment descriptor
  (/WEB-INF/web.xml) to declare the JNDI name under which
  you will request new instances of this bean.  The simplest approach is
  to use a<resource-env-ref>element, like this: |  |  |  |  |  | 
<resource-env-ref>
  <description>
    Object factory for MyBean instances.
  </description>
  <resource-env-ref-name>
    bean/MyBeanFactory
  </resource-env-ref-name>
  <resource-env-ref-type>
    com.mycompany.MyBean
  </resource-env-ref-type>
</resource-env-ref>
 |  |  |  |  |  | 
WARNING - Be sure you respect the element ordering
    that is required by the DTD for web application deployment descriptors!
    See the
    Servlet
    Specification for details. 3.  Code Your Application's Use Of This ResourceA typical use of this resource environment reference might look
  like this: |  |  |  |  |  | 
Context initCtx = new InitialContext();
Context envCtx = (Context) initCtx.lookup("java:comp/env");
MyBean bean = (MyBean) envCtx.lookup("bean/MyBeanFactory");
writer.println("foo = " + bean.getFoo() + ", bar = " +
               bean.getBar());
 |  |  |  |  |  | 
4.  Configure Tomcat's Resource FactoryTo configure Tomcat's resource factory, add an elements like this to the
    <Context>element for
    this web application. |  |  |  |  |  | 
<Context ...>
  ...
  <Resource name="bean/MyBeanFactory" auth="Container"
            type="com.mycompany.MyBean"
            factory="com.mycompany.MyBeanFactory"
            bar="23"/>
  ...
</Context>
 |  |  |  |  |  | 
Note that the resource name (here, bean/MyBeanFactorymust match the value specified in the web application deployment
    descriptor.  We are also initializing the value of thebarproperty, which will causesetBar(23)to be called before
    the new bean is returned.  Because we are not initializing thefooproperty (although we could have), the bean will
    contain whatever default value is set up by its constructor. You will also note that, from the application developer's perspective,
    the declaration of the resource environment reference, and the programming
    used to request new instances, is identical to the approach used for the
    Generic JavaBean Resources example.  This illustrates one of the
    advantages of using JNDI resources to encapsulate functionality - you can
    change the underlying implementation without necessarily having to
    modify applications using the resources, as long as you maintain
    compatible APIs. | 
 |